top of page

A hotelier’s notes from South Wales, in two halves

For owners, by Pedro Reis

For guests, by Nia

 

 

 

Get an earnings estimate

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Would I keep more if I managed it myself?

4 days ago
5 min read
The Loft, 82 Cathedral Road, Cardiff

Yes. If two identical short lets take the same bookings, the self-managed one leaves its owner with more money: about £6,240 a year more in the worked example below. A manager at 15% plus VAT earns the fee by bringing in more bookings than you would on your own, or by giving you back about 310 hours a year.


I manage short lets in Cardiff, Newport and Cwmbran, so I have an interest. I have tried to write this as if I did not.


The worked example

This is an illustration built on stated assumptions. It is not a Guesture result or a forecast for your property.


The property: a two-bedroom flat in a South Wales city, taking £40,000 a year in bookings across about 80 stays.


The assumptions, the same on both sides unless stated:


  • Booking platforms keep 15% of booking value. Real rates vary by platform, and direct bookings carry none.

  • Each stay needs a clean and a linen change at £60.

  • A self-managing owner pays £80 a month for a channel manager and a pricing tool. A managed owner does not, because the manager supplies them.

  • The management fee is 15% of gross booking value, plus VAT at 20%, and the owner cannot reclaim the VAT. That is our Full Management fee.

  • A self-managing owner spends six hours a week on the property.



Self-managed

Managed at 15% + VAT

Booking revenue

£40,000

£40,000

Platform commission (15%)

−£6,000

−£6,000

Cleaning and linen (80 × £60)

−£4,800

−£4,800

Software

−£960

£0

Management fee (15%)

£0

−£6,000

VAT on the fee

£0

−£1,200

Left for the owner

£28,240

£22,000

Owner's time

about 310 hours a year

an hour or so a month


"Left for the owner" is before utilities, council tax or business rates, insurance, repairs and the mortgage. Those are the same either way.


On identical bookings, the self-managing owner is £6,240 a year better off.


What that £6,240 buys

It buys about 310 hours of your year. £6,240 divided by 312 hours is £20 an hour.


Six hours a week is my assumption, and you should change it. It covers answering enquiries, messaging guests, changing prices, booking cleaners and checking their work, restocking, arranging repairs and keeping the listings up to date. An owner who lives round the corner from one well-run flat may do it in less. An owner an hour away will spend more.


The hours also have a shape. They are not six tidy hours on a Tuesday morning. They are a lock-out at midnight, a cleaner who cancels at 8am on a changeover day, and a guest question in the middle of your working day.


So the first question is this: would you do this job for £20 an hour, on call every day of the year? Some people would, and enjoy it. For one home near where you live, self-managing can be the right choice.


What a manager has to earn to be worth the fee

The second question is whether a manager would take the same bookings as you. If they would, you are paying for time and nothing else. If they take more, the sums change.


In the example, each extra £1 of bookings leaves the managed owner with about 67p after platform commission, the fee and VAT. To match the self-managing owner's £28,240, the managed flat has to take about £49,300. That is 23% more than the £40,000. More bookings need more cleans, so treat 23% as the minimum.


Here is one real reference point. We managed a two-bedroom flat in Cardiff city centre for three full calendar years. It took £139,178 in bookings. The average night sold for between £181 and £194 in all three years, and the best month came to £8,217. The full case file is here.


Where a manager usually finds extra bookings:


  • Pricing by date. In Cardiff that means Six Nations weekends, autumn internationals, stadium concerts and graduation weeks set weeks ahead, and quiet weeks priced to sell.

  • More channels. Airbnb plus Booking.com, Vrbo, Expedia and direct bookings, from one calendar.

  • Filling gaps. Opening the single nights between bookings that most owners leave blocked.


If your flat is on one platform at one price, this is where a manager finds the 23%.


The middle road

You do not have to choose between everything and nothing. Our Distribution Only tier is 12% plus VAT. We run your listings across the platforms from one calendar, with commission-free direct bookings, and you keep the guests, the check-ins, the cleaning and the maintenance. On the example flat that fee would be £4,800, plus £960 VAT.


What stays the same either way

Some costs and duties do not move when you hire a manager.


  • Platform commission. A manager works with Airbnb and Booking.com, not instead of them.

  • Cleaning. Someone is paid for every changeover.

  • The Wales register. Every provider of visitor accommodation must register with the Welsh Revenue Authority. It is free, and the deadline is 31 March 2027 if you were already letting. The provider is normally the owner. On Full Management we do the registration for you, but the duty stays yours.

  • The Cardiff visitor levy. From 1 April 2027, £1.30 per person per night on stays in Cardiff, paid by the guest, however the property is managed.

  • Insurance, safety certificates and repairs. Yours in both cases.


A quick decision guide

Self-managing probably suits you if:


  • you have one property and live within about 20 minutes of it

  • you have flexible hours and you like dealing with guests

  • you have a cleaner you trust, and a backup


A manager probably suits you if:


  • you live far from the property, or abroad

  • your working day cannot stop for a guest message

  • your listing is on one platform at one price, and you know it

  • you would not do the job for £20 an hour


Try it with your own numbers

  1. Take last year's bookings. Subtract platform commission and cleaning.

  2. For the self-managed side, subtract your software costs and write down your hours honestly.

  3. For the managed side, subtract 15% plus VAT.

  4. Divide the difference by your hours. That is what you are paying yourself.

  5. Ask the manager what they would expect the property to take, and ask to see the comparable homes behind that figure.


Then set the two figures side by side.


Questions owners ask

Is an Airbnb management company worth it?

It is worth it when the manager brings in enough extra bookings to cover the fee, or when your time is worth more than the fee costs. In the worked example at 15% plus VAT, the manager needs to take about 23% more in bookings for the owner to break even in cash.


How much does Guesture charge?

12%, 15% or 20% of gross booking value, plus VAT, depending on the tier. Full Management is 15% plus VAT. Platform commission and cleaning are charged by the platforms and the cleaners, whoever manages the property. The services page sets out each tier.


Who deals with the Cardiff visitor levy if I use a manager?

The guest pays it: £1.30 per person per night from 1 April 2027. For the homes we manage, we will collect it from guests and pay it to the Welsh Revenue Authority. Our fee is not charged on it.


Want the managed side of the sum for your own property? Send me the address, and last year's bookings if you have them. Ask for an earnings estimate.


Pedro Reis, Founder, Guesture

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

Planning a visit to Cardiff or Newport?

Get our new local guides by email, with 10% off your first direct stay in one of our homes.

Thank you. Your code is on its way to your inbox.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

View the home

 

 

View the home

 

 

View the home

What could your property take?

Send us the address, and last year’s bookings if you have them. Within one working day we will tell you what we think it could take, based on homes we have run. Free, and no obligation.

The other half of this journal

Staying with us, not letting with us?

Nia, who looks after our guests, keeps The Guide: Cardiff, Newport and Cwmbran by place and by occasion, with the homes nearby on every page.

Stay with us in Cardiff or Newport.

Every home in The Guide is one we look after ourselves. Book direct with our own local team for our best rate.

The other half of this journal

Own a property in Cardiff or Newport?

Proof is where Pedro Reis, our founder, shows what our homes have done: case files, straight answers and what we charge.

bottom of page